Judge Rules Church Can Protect Funds From Abuse Settlements
Federal Judge Rudolph T Randa issued a
ruling this Wednesday that the Archdiocese of Milwaukee can legally prevent $57 million from going to settlements in the church's ongoing sexual abuse scandals by transferring the funds into a trust fund designed for the upkeep and maintenance of Milwaukee Catholic cemeteries. The Archdiocese of Milwaukee had filed for bankruptcy largely in part due to the hefty amount the church owes in sexual abuse settlements, and the case was trying to determine if the $57 million can be included in the Church's assets.
The decision was made based on legal requirements outlined by the Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA) that state the government may not put a "substantial burden" on religious entities. However, the RFRA does stipulate an exception if the burden is "in furtherance of a compelling governmental interest and is the lease restrictive means of furthering that interest." Judge Randa declared the RFRA exception not applicable for the Archdiocese of Milwaukee's bankruptcy case because the "interests advances by the bankruptcy system are not compelling."
Many advocates working to prevent sexual abuse within the church believe the interests in this case are very compelling. Advocates cite 45 individual priests within the Archdiocese of Milwaukee accused of committing sexual assault, with one priest accused of molesting almost 200 deaf boys.
The intentions to withhold the $57 million from sexual abuse settlements by the church stand out clearly through the words of former Archbishop, now Cardinal, Timothy Dolan in a letter he wrote to the Vatican in 2007. In the letter, one of many documents publically released in July, he states that transferring the funds into the cemetery trust fund would lead to "an improved protection of these funds from any legal claim and liability." Dolan is also the president of United States Conference of Catholic Bishops.
The ruling dealt down by Judge Randa has serious implications for those seeking settlement money from any religious institutions in the future. In particular the decision sets a precedent for any religious organization to protect any funds they deem appropriately theirs through redistributing their assets.
Media Resources: Opposing Views 7/31/2013; ThinkProgress 7/31/2013; New York Times 7/2/2013; Feminist Newswire 7/2/2013
© Feminist Majority Foundation, publisher of Ms. magazine If you liked this story, consider making a tax-deductible donation to support Ms. magazine .
Send to a Friend
More Feminist News
- The US Senate voted 62 to 38 yesterday Senate Votes to Advance "Fast Tracking" of Dangerous Trade Agreement to advance "fast track" trade legislation, just one week after Senate Democrats filibustered the controversial bill that would allow President Obama to force Congress to vote up-or-down on the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) agreement.
The TPP is a far-reaching trade agreement that has faced staunch opposition from a broad coalition of labor, environmental, women's rights, and human rights groups. . . .
- Following a report by the New York Times on the exploitation of nail salon workers almost two weeks ago, New York state and city officials have partnered with advocates and volunteers to bring comprehensive educational programs and labor reforms to the 5,000 licensed salons in the state.
Governor Andrew Cuomo (D), New York Politicians, Advocates, and Activists Have Come Together to Protect Nail Salon Workers who ordered emergency measures last week in the wake of the report - including posting workers' rights information in salons in different languages, shutting down unlicensed salons, implementing new safety requirements, and creating an educational campaign aimed at employees and managers - has introduced a legislative package aimed at building upon those reforms and leading the way for long-term protection for nail salon workers. . . .
- New York Attorney General Eric Schneiderman introduced the New York Attorney General Moves to Expand Access to Contraceptives Comprehensive Contraception Coverage Act of 2015 last week to enhance the availability of contraception for New Yorkers.
The bill codifies the federal Affordable Care Act (ACA) in New York state law while strengthening and expanding many of its provisions. . . .